A little into last night’s game, I caught myself yelling at the TV over a “disconcerting signals” call (more on that later). I realized I had reverted back to what I had tried so fervently to avoid this year. See, people who exploit the young athletes, people who make fortunes from the work of students who – by rule – are unpaid, can only continue their nefariousness as long as fans believe that the sport actually matters. In fact, football doesn’t matter.
I’ve done better this year than last (when I had four or five games simultaneously streaming to my desktop), but I still found myself telling a four-year-old, “We can play catch at halftime.” So I stopped watching. I stood up, ignored a play or two, and tossed a Nerf football into his little arms. As the score narrowed, the eight-year-old joined us. The game, its players, its rules, faded into the background of real life nonsense.
I admit I cheered the game-winning touchdown, but it was fitting that it was scored by a new father. He would go home filled with emotion, and then hold a baby who doesn’t care – doesn’t even know – about what he did.
We’ve all seen pictures of athletes shedding tears of joy or sorrow over respective successes or failures. The effort these individuals expend in search of achievement justifies their emotion. But we’ve also seen the little children, decked out by their parents in a team’s garb, bawling when their parents’ team loses. Though not pathetic for the child, it’s indicative of how pathetic a society we have become.
Where does this put me for next year? Will I attempt to kick my habit cold turkey? Or will I keep watching without losing perspective? We’ll see.
—–
On the issue of disconcerting signals
Many casual football fans don’t know what “disconcerting signals” are, and many have never seen it called. The quick rule is this: A defensive player cannot yell “HIKE!” It really is a cheap, dishonest, and illegal technique, and it’s a pet peeve of mine.
Over the last few seasons, I’ve noticed this becoming more and more of an issue. The worst was when Air Force, under a first-year coach, was caught doing it. I have some attachment to USAFA. One of my dissertation advisors and a close friend taught there. I consulted with their language faculty. I have a profound respect for the cadets. So I hit the roof when their football team employed such an unsportsmanlike cheat.
So the first outburst I had last night was when – on the first false start of the game – the defense was hit with a 15-yard penalty for disconcerting signals. I think I yelled something like, “Eat it, cheaters!” By the way, that offense wasn’t called for another false start the entire game.
—–
On the Mountain West Standings
The final Mountain West Conference standings wholly demonstrate the transitive property of competition. The principle is that if Team A defeats Team B, and Team B defeats Team C, then Team A should defeat Team C. Of course, life is rarely this clearly cut, but this year was one of those times.
| Team | Defeated | Defeated by |
| TCU | BYU, Utah, AF, Wyoming, UNLV, SDSU, NMU, CSU | |
| BYU | Utah, AF, Wyoming, UNLV, SDSU, NMU, CSU | TCU |
| Utah | AF, Wyoming, UNLV, SDSU, NMU, CSU | TCU, BYU |
| AF | Wyoming, UNLV, SDSU, NMU, CSU | TCU, BYU, Utah |
| Wyoming | UNLV, SDSU, NMU, CSU | TCU, BYU, Utah, AF |
| UNLV | SDSU, NMU, CSU | TCU, BYU, Utah, AF, Wyoming |
| SDSU | NMU, CSU | TCU, BYU, Utah, AF, Wyoming, UNLV |
| NMU | CSU | TCU, BYU, Utah, AF, Wyoming, UNLV, SDSU |
| CSU | TCU, BYU, Utah, AF, Wyoming, UNLV, SDSU, NMU |
—–
On TCU (and Boise St. and Cincinnati) and the BCS
I heard a CBS analyst say that three teams still control their own destiny in pursuit of the BCS championship: Texas, Florida, and Alabama. In sports, controlling one’s own destiny refers to a condition wherein if a team keeps winning, they will win the championship/win the pennant/make the playoffs/etc. If you do not control you own destiny, it’s because you lost somewhere along the way and you need another team to lose – even if you win the rest of your games.
The idea that there are three teams who do not control their own destiny even though they have not lost a game is antithetical to honest competition. This season proves, more than any other, that college football is the only sport where players who have qualified to compete at the same level are not allowed to.





