Smash Lab, which Discovery is trying to piggyback on Mythbusters, isn’t bad, just like Hershey’s kisses aren’t bad. But if you eat a kiss right after savoring a piece of Ghirardelli Toffee Interlude, it will taste like wax. Likewise, watching Smash Lab after Jamie and Adam’s antics only serves to drive home the point that more money does not make a better show.
Mythbusters excels on two points: 1) They don’t sweat the small stuff, which causes some amusing incidents in the workshop (Mike on Dirty Jobs does the same), but 2) when the chips are down, the Mythbusters are attentive enough to make sure the myth gets tested with reasonable accuracy.
Smash Lab gets it backwards: They pull out all the stops during development, welding where Mythbusters would duct tape, using specialized machinery where the Mythbusters would fab their own, but then they skimp on things like experimental controls. They are also prone to making last-minute, untested adjustments to their experiments. Lame.
I hope Discovery did not pay for Smash Lab with the cash they saved by not sponsoring the greatest cycling team ever. I also hope Smash Lab goes the way of “Build it Bigger.”